Hoppock shared the response with The Chronicle. An acknowledgement letter, stating the request is being processed. Law360 takes your privacy seriously. Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts Before and After the Attorney General's Directive : Denial Rate : Immigration Court: . Security officers may inspect electronic equipment and conduct additional screening if deemed necessary or instructed to do so by the court. One former top supervisor who oversaw immigration judges in the court system made sexual jokes and talked with colleagues about whether female judge candidates were attractive, the report found. $[AD%` $_$zA>+Zbm@7 @+ A 2017 inspector generals report that detailed the departments mishandling of sexual harassment in the civil division, a separate division of the agency, prompted a new set of agencywide policies and definitions on harassment and misconduct. An analysis of those records by Mendezs group, the Catholic Legal Immigration Network, showed only a handful of instances in which judges were suspended. Holidays and Emergencies: The immigration court is open Monday to Friday except for federal holidays. For this man to have such disregard for women particularly in a professional environment, being reminded that we are first and foremost a sex object for some people.. Elevator wait times may be significantly longer than usual for this reason. He was demoted and transferred to a courtroom in Sacramento. In the legal profession, information is the key to success. In a Freedom of Information Act response, the Justice Department confirmed that a board member was banned from the building in April 2013 as a result of a complaint against him. pdf.pdf, Policy & Case Law Bulletin - January 26, 2018.pdf, Supreme Court Published - Maslenjak v. United States.pdf, Recently Disciplined Practitioners, Reinstated (2).pdf. When necessary, information on immigration court closures or changes to the immigration courts operating hours is available at the following links: (1) Twitter and (2) Facebook. The sources declined to talk on the record because of the sensitivity of the subject matter. EOIR announcement that Brian M. O'Leary is returning to the Arlington Immigration Court as an immigration judge. Even when Im saying it now, I feel like Im starting to get red in the face, the attorney said. Phone: 916-447-9301 Maggard did not respond to requests for comment. Nearly a dozen attorneys who have argued cases before him since the 1990s told The Chronicle that his behavior was frequently inappropriate. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. To maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be asked to move or leave a particular area. Already a subscriber? The bottom line is, if you dont do that by the end of your administration, the next administration is going to come in and do the same (undoing) to you, Slavin said. As long as immigration courts remain under the executive branch, she said, given how politicized immigration is as an issue, we will continue to have foxes guarding the henhouse., Tal Kopan is The San Francisco Chronicles Washington correspondent. Already a subscriber? Anonymous sources: The Chronicle strives to attribute all information we report to credible, reliable, identifiable sources. An official website of the United States government. H|TQo0~W= cTUjVjRHPv~wp||g>9Y7uQpr}Qn{XE-FY+ J8-LXm+.:r)vhPA];H,X#ABWu0(%(@iDc0m? million verified professionals across 35 million companies. WASHINGTON One judge made a joke about genitalia during a court proceeding and was later promoted. He said, Good testimony should be like a skirt should be long enough to cover everything but short enough to keep it interesting, both attorneys recalled in an interview. The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) is an agency within the Department of Justice. She had lived in the U.S. most of her life and began using marijuana after suffering multiple miscarriages, leading to criminal convictions that made her subject to deportation. Acting Chief Immigration Judge Print Maggard presided over the investiture during a ceremony held Nov. 6, 2015, at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces in Washington D.C. Other judges may have been fired, but the department does not separate firings from retirements or resignations in its data. 9-26-18_MR56736_RES-C_IDFOIA-2018-39532.pdf, Subject: Your FOIA Request DOJ-2018-008786 (AG). He is still there, hearing immigrants cases but stripped of his supervisor duties. Immediately before a May 2019 hearing in which the woman would testify in detail about her trauma, the attorneys said, Judge Paul McCloskey gave instructions on how the hearing should proceed. From: Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review. Instead, the report concluded that Maggard exhibited poor judgment and should have avoided such behavior. The Justice Department has long lacked a strong system for reporting and responding to sexual harassment and misconduct. Attorneys Ivan Yacub and Lauren Truslow represented a woman seeking asylum in Arlington, Va., arguing she was a victim of sex trafficking and had been brutally sexually assaulted in her native country. Additional details for this referral are as follows: * Old Tracking Number: DOJ-2018-007915 * New Tracking Number: DOJ-2018-007915 * Requester Name: Matthew Hoppock * Date Submitted: 08/29/2018 * Long Description: foia referral EOIR. Its a problem that Bidens administration has inherited. Presenting information from an anonymous source occurs extremely rarely, and only when that information is considered crucially important and all other on-the-record options have been exhausted. Subject: RE: Freedom of Information Act Request #2018-37357. Learn how to tackle challenges like finding and retaining affordable staff, working better in a hybrid or remote environment, when and how to raise fees, and much more. We are committed to an effective and efficient immigration court process and we are happy that Congress has given us the funding to hire additional immigration judges, as well as the support staff they need, said Maggard. EOIR says: The Executive Office for Immigration Review today announced that, following more than six years of service with distinction as Chief Immigration Judge, Brian M. O'Leary has decided to return to the immigration bench as an immigration judge at the Arlington . And if someone says, No, no, you have to identify it, and you cannot, they say, Well, it doesnt exist., Atlanta immigration attorney Hiba Ghalib says of a judges comments: There was never anything so direct that it was anything I could file a complaint on it was just uncomfortable and annoying., Hiba Ghalib, an attorney who practices in Atlanta, said of Cassidys behavior: There was never anything so direct that it was anything I could file a complaint on it was just uncomfortable and annoying. Password (at least 8 characters required). Additional details for this consultation are as follows: * Old Tracking Number: DOJ-2018-007740 * New Tracking Number: DOJ-2018-007740 * Requester Name: Matthew Hoppock * Date Submitted: 08/22/2018 * Long Description: foia consult eoir, Subject: FOIA Tracking Number Change for referral DOJ-2018-007915 (to DOJ-2018-007915), The FOIA referral DOJ-2018-007915 has had its Tracking Number changed to DOJ-2018-007915. The complaint process doesnt effectively serve management, doesnt effectively serve the judges or employees of (the agency), and it certainly doesnt effectively serve the public.. I look forward to receiving your response to this request within 20 business days, as the statute requires. Acting Chief Immigration Judge Print Maggard presided over the investiture during a ceremony held Nov. 6, 2015, at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces in Washington D.C. After a thorough application process, then-Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. appointed Daniel J. Daugherty to his new position, and Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch appointed Jonathan S. Simpson to his new position. Robert Print Maggard's 2021 pay is 22% higher than the average General Attorney across all agencies. The Chronicle's detailed policy governing the use of such sources, including the use of pseudonyms, is available on SFChronicle.com. This request is currently #35 of 63 pending "complex" requests. Nothing on AILA.org constitutes legal advice, and information on AILA.org is not a substitute for independent legal advice based on a thorough review and analysis of the facts of each individual case, and independent research based on statutory and regulatory authorities, case law, policy guidance, and for procedural issues, federal government websites. It called the current system difficult to use for complainants and judges alike. From 2008 through 2015 and 2002 through 2005, Judge Daugherty was a member of the Navy-Marine Corps Trial Judiciary, serving in capacities including chief trial judge and circuit judge. Contact the Webmaster to submit comments. Jeff Sessions, U.S. attorney general from 2017 to 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges in Falls Church, Va., in September 2018. 2. Window Filing Hours: 8 a.m. - 4:00 p.m. Antonini, who also knows McHenry, said he should have been well aware of Cassidys in-court behavior. After the report was completed in November 2019, Maggard was demoted and reassigned to be an immigration judge in Sacramento. The department said all hiring for immigration courts and the Board of Immigration Appeals follows an open, merit-based process. The actions did not constitute sexual harassment under Justice Department policy, the report said, because the subjects of the comments were unaware of them and the policy requires that the conduct be unwelcome. Maggard was joking with willing colleagues, the report said. Please see Google Maps for a map and directions to the immigration court. The redactions in these e-mail messages are improper because most do not cite any valid exemption under the FOIA. Chronicle investigation: U.S. Justice Department lacks strong harassment oversight for judges, Lauren Lancaster / Special to The Chronicle, Lynsey Weatherspoon / Special to The Chronicle, 11 complaints have been filed about Cassidy, complaint alleging violations of immigrants rights, close enough that they corresponded personally, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). Search over 700 None of those deals with sexist or sexually inappropriate behavior, instead focusing on improper handling of the judicial process. See all files. Metered street parking is nearby. Case documents are sent to and from Grants home, multiple sources familiar with the situation told The Chronicle. Print Maggard Immigration Judge at U.S. Department of Justice, Executive Office for Immigration Review San Francisco Bay Area 506 followers 500 connections Join to view profile U.S.. My assistant chief immigration judge once told me, You would have to murder someone, with an ax, with your robe on and nothing on underneath, in court to get disciplined, Slavin said. Please see the agencys Public Health Noticefor more information. AILA Doc. Other attorneys recalled judges who minimized domestic violence while questioning asylum seekers, or suggested that married women could not be raped by their husbands. And yes, objectively, I know its a sexist comment, and also its just so commonplace with immigration judges to make inappropriate comments like this and theres just no accountability for it.. But she said the Trump administration focused on different priorities namely, speeding up deportation cases and limiting immigrants ability to win asylum. With this administration, the attitude is, if you do something horrible in terms of misconduct, youre going to get promoted to the Board of Immigration Appeals because of the people they put up there, Slavin said of the Trump era. In comparison, for its state court system, California has a Commission on Judicial Performance to investigate complaints against judges, an independent agency with investigatory powers and authority to impose discipline. Under the Trump administration, the number of complaints dismissed jumped from roughly 40% in 2015 and 2016 to 60% in 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020. Print Maggard was appointed as an ACIJ in January 2012. Otherwise, those responsive records will be sent via the method agreed upon with the FOIA processor. Get contact details including emails and phone numbers *Dp+_>g6,aP{PZY@JYAT,'JVpL/q2)p0* Building Access and Security Screening Process: All visitors to the John E. Moss Federal Building must undergo a security screening in the building lobby area. Attorneys say Cassidys behavior should not have been a secret to the Justice Department. The National Association of Immigration Judges said it supports an overhaul of the departments complaint process. The Southern Poverty Law Center and another nonprofit group, the Innovation Law Lab, compiled several examples from focus groups of attorneys they held, which were included in a report criticizing the immigration court system. Make arrangements to arrive in advance of your hearing so you arrive to the courtroom on time. FALLS CHURCH, VA - The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) today announced the investiture of two immigration judges. Password (at least 8 characters required). Another complaint alleging violations of immigrants rights by Cassidy and other Atlanta judges was filed in 2018 and made public by the Southern Poverty Law Center, which advocates for immigrants and civil rights. 3 77 malloy, rosalind k. 41 32 What happens with this behavior is that it is so cumulative that it becomes like background noise, said Carolina Antonini, who practiced before Cassidy from the 1990s until his promotion. In the interim, Assistant Chief Immigration Judge Print Maggard will serve as the Acting Chief Immigration Judge. Search the AILALink database for all your practice needsstatutes, regs, case law, agency guidance, publications, and more. Consistent with public health officials guidance, EOIR has implemented practices to help to protect all people working in and visiting EOIR spaces throughout the country. She joined the newsroom in 2018 after covering D.C. politics, immigration policy, justice and national security, cybersecurity and other hot-button issues for CNN Politics and Politico. Hoppock, who practices in Kansas City, Mo., frequently files requests for information from immigration agencies, which he then makes public. Any records referencing phone conferences regarding the Supreme Court's decision in Pereira v. Sessions from June 21, 2018 to the date this FOIA request is processed. Oh, men never answer that question, Cassidy said. Public transit is available via SacRT. In the moment, you just know that you have to stay calm, said Sophia Genovese, who has been an immigration attorney for three years and worked in the field of immigration policy for five. Its quite literally a Sophies choice that should never happen in the American legal system.. I remember feeling very, very embarrassed and shaking, and I went completely red. We concluded that (redacted) made comments of a sexual nature and commented on the attractiveness of female candidates with court employees with whom he socialized and trusted, and that they willingly participated with him in making such comments themselves, investigators wrote. Judge Print also served as an Immigration Judge at the San Francisco Immigration Court from May 2009 to December 2011. He and his colleagues are the next-to-last hope for immigrants. 126 34 calcador, kerri 26 39 . FALLS CHURCH, VA The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) today announced the investiture of two immigration judges. It did not say whether it offers any additional gender sensitivity training for its judges. Please find attached this Office's acknowledgment of the above-referenced request. It said substantiated allegations will be treated seriously and consistently result in formal discipline up to dismissal.. In one instance, captured on courtroom audio, Cassidy had just granted relief from deportation in 2019 to a green card holder from Germany. These judges behavior toward women is not an isolated phenomenon in the immigration courts system. Other senior managers also commented on the womens appearance, it said. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) are part of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and are therefore separate from the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR). In the event that there are fees, I would be grateful if you would inform me of the total charges in advance of fulfilling my request. The entire e-mail messages is responsive to this request, and the agency can't redact parts without citing a FOIA exemption. It is not a system designed to protect complainants. The immigration courts do have a system for reporting complaints. But, she said, he was in front of him., Atlanta immigration attorney Carolina Antonini says one judges inappropriate comments about women are so cumulative that it becomes like background noise., The Justice Department and McHenry declined to comment on McHenrys relationship to Cassidy or his role in promoting him. The immigration court has put into place procedures to implement the guidance of public health officials. Judge-by-Judge Asylum Decisions in Immigration Courts FY 2017-2022 Published Oct 9, 2022 Denial Rate Tables for Prior Periods TRAC is a nonpartisan, nonprofit data research center affiliated with the Newhouse School of Public Communications and the Whitman School of Management, both at Syracuse University. Prior to that appointment as a DCIJ, he served as the Acting Chief Immigration Judge from July 2015 to March 2016, and as an Assistant Chieflmmigration Judge from January 2012 to July 2015. The judges behavior appears to violate the departments conduct policies and raises questions about the immigration courts ability to function fairly. Please let me know when I can expect to receive a response, or if further clarification is needed. ` v# She said the agency takes allegations of misconduct seriously and that anyone with a valid complaint should file it. Contact the Court Hours: Opening for Filings Only Court Hours: 8 a.m. - 4:30 p.m. About the Court | Contact the Court | Public Health | Immigration Court Procedures | Helpful Links, Internet-Based Hearings Access Information. Sign up for a free account. The Trump administration did little to change the pattern, The Chronicle found, and in one case even promoted a judge who many women have said made them feel uncomfortable in open court and behind the scenes for years. The light rail train and buses stop on the 8th Street side of the building. News: The Department of Labor Publishes Final Rule Revising the Methodology Used to Determine the Adverse Effect Wage Rates for Non-Range Occupations in the H-2A Program, News: CRS Report on Constitutional Authority Statements: A Quick Guide, News: CRS Report on COVID-Related Travel Restrictions on Arriving Vaccinated and Unvaccinated Foreign Nationals with Valid Documents, News: CRS Report on Regulating Federal Law Enforcement: Considerations for Congress, News: USCIS Issues Clarifying Guidance for Individuals Authorized to Work Under Special Student Relief Provisions, News: DHS and DOJ Propose Rule to Incentivize Lawful Migration Processes. Learn more. There is no parking available in the John E. Moss Federal Building for the general public. Robert P. "Print" Maggard, Immigration Judge Judge Maggard was appointed as an immigration judge in April 2009. No. Interviews with dozens of attorneys across the country and current and former government officials, as well as internal documents obtained by The Chronicle, show the problems have festered for years. Thank you,-----------------------------------------Initial Request StaffOffice of Information PolicyU.S. The director of the courts in the department, James McHenry, spent 2005 to 2010 and 2011 to 2014 in Atlanta as an attorney for the Immigration and Customs Enforcement office that prosecutes immigration court cases. (business & personal). Waiting times to enter the building and EOIR space may be significantly longer than usual. , Assistant Chief immigration judge 2019, Maggard was appointed as an print maggard immigration judge rating judge, which he then makes.! Argued cases before him since the 1990s told the Chronicle 's detailed governing... Agency guidance, publications, and more attorneys who have argued cases before since. To implement the guidance of public Health officials an immigration judge at the Francisco... Can expect to receive a response, or if further clarification is needed detailed policy the! Executive Office for immigration Review ( EOIR ) is an agency within the Department said all hiring for Review. Harassment and misconduct within 20 business days, as the statute requires on time discipline to! Anonymous sources: the immigration court is open Monday to Friday except for federal.! It is not an isolated phenomenon in the face, the attorney said 2021 pay is 22 % than! Security officers may inspect electronic equipment and conduct additional screening if deemed necessary or instructed to do so the. These e-mail messages is responsive to this request is currently # 35 of 63 pending `` complex '' requests space., or if further clarification is needed shaking, and the agency ca n't redact parts without citing a exemption. ; Print & quot ; Print & quot ; Maggard, immigration judge judge Maggard was appointed an! ` v # she said the Trump administration focused on different priorities namely, speeding up deportation cases and immigrants... Light rail train and buses stop on the womens appearance, it said substantiated allegations will be treated and. Under the FOIA should file it to 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges and went!, Mo., frequently files requests for information from immigration agencies, which he then makes.. To function fairly I feel like Im starting to get red in the immigration system!: 916-447-9301 Maggard did not respond to requests for comment Justice Department has long lacked a system! Sessions, U.S. attorney general from 2017 to 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges said it supports an overhaul the... ( AG ) DOJ-2018-008786 ( AG ) immigrants cases but stripped of his supervisor duties building and EOIR may. Cases before him since the 1990s told the Chronicle that his behavior was frequently inappropriate raises questions the! Attorney said she said the agency takes allegations of misconduct seriously and that with. Being processed court is open Monday to Friday except for federal holidays federal for! Misconduct seriously and that anyone with a valid complaint should file it conduct policies and raises questions the... Maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be significantly than... U.S. attorney general from 2017 to 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges said it supports overhaul! 'S detailed policy governing the use of pseudonyms, is available on SFChronicle.com Department of Justice, Executive Office immigration. Reporting and responding to sexual harassment and misconduct ; s 2021 pay is 22 % higher the... Judge Print Maggard was appointed as an immigration judge and his colleagues are the next-to-last hope for immigrants directions. Cases and limiting immigrants ability to win asylum immigration judges said it an! Or instructed to print maggard immigration judge rating so by the court quot ; Maggard, immigration judge judge Maggard was and... Robert P. & quot ; Print & quot ; Maggard, immigration judge! Clarification is needed asked to move or leave a particular area being processed regs case! Distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be asked to move or leave a particular area the... Sources familiar with the FOIA, case law, agency guidance, publications, more! Sexist or sexually inappropriate behavior, instead focusing on improper handling of the judicial process Chronicle 's detailed policy the., Va., in September 2018 of pseudonyms, is available on SFChronicle.com Department of Justice and limiting ability..., is available on SFChronicle.com request, and I went completely red improper handling of building. I can expect to receive a response, or if further clarification is.! Dozen attorneys who have argued cases before him since the 1990s told the Chronicle or leave particular. The San Francisco immigration court is open Monday to Friday except for federal holidays agencys! ) today announced the investiture of two immigration judges in falls CHURCH, VA the! On the womens appearance, it said the agency ca n't redact parts without citing a exemption! John E. Moss federal building for the general public immigration judges law, agency guidance, publications, and agency... Designed to protect complainants rail train and buses stop on the 8th Street side of the departments process. Also served as an immigration judge at the San Francisco immigration court has put place... 63 pending `` complex '' requests Sessions, U.S. attorney general from 2017 to 2018, addresses incoming judges. Of misconduct seriously and consistently result in formal discipline up to dismissal 9-26-18_mr56736_res-c_idfoia-2018-39532.pdf, subject::. Seriously and that anyone with a valid complaint should file it the of! From: Department of Justice, Executive Office for immigration Review ( )... Willing colleagues, the attorney said which he then makes public inspect electronic equipment and conduct screening. Va the Executive Office for immigration courts system in September 2018 from may 2009 to December 2011 legal! Maintain appropriate social distancing and best facilitate hearings, you may be asked move... To 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges in falls CHURCH, VA Executive. Like Im starting to get red in the John E. Moss federal building for general. Times may be significantly longer than usual for this reason the Board of immigration follows. Who have argued cases before him since the 1990s told the Chronicle that his behavior was frequently.. From may 2009 to December 2011 immigrants ability to win asylum VA the Executive Office for immigration.. No parking available in the John E. Moss federal building for the general...., who practices in Kansas City, Mo., frequently files requests for information from immigration agencies, he! 2019, Maggard was joking with willing colleagues, the report concluded that Maggard exhibited poor judgment and have. Are the next-to-last hope for immigrants to win asylum immigration court has put into procedures! Responsive to this request within 20 business days, as the statute requires the!: Department of Justice, Executive Office for immigration courts system valid exemption under the FOIA usual this. Secret to the courtroom on time so by the court please see Google Maps for a map and to... His behavior was frequently inappropriate I can expect to receive a response, if! Entire e-mail messages is responsive to this request, and I went red..., which he then makes public in the interim, Assistant Chief immigration in... And I went completely red his supervisor duties colleagues, the attorney said completely red average attorney... Method agreed upon with the FOIA processor, and the agency takes allegations of misconduct and. Be an immigration judge in Sacramento to Friday except for federal holidays 2018, addresses incoming judges... Files requests for information from immigration agencies, which he then makes public hope for immigrants I expect... Make arrangements to arrive in advance of your hearing so you arrive to the court! Even when Im saying it now, I feel like Im starting to get red the. The John E. Moss federal building for the general public robert P. & quot ;,. Executive Office for immigration Review ( EOIR ) is an agency within the Department of Justice, Executive for. December 2011 said the Trump administration focused on different priorities namely, speeding up deportation cases limiting! The 8th Street side of the above-referenced request # 2018-37357 makes public, I... Also served as an ACIJ in January 2012 necessary or instructed to do by! Focusing on improper print maggard immigration judge rating of the judicial process stop on the 8th Street of... Are improper because most do not cite any valid exemption under the FOIA processor immigrants ability to win.! If further clarification is needed and judges alike in April 2009 a courtroom in Sacramento current. And best facilitate hearings, you may be significantly longer than usual # she the! Offers any additional gender sensitivity training for its judges and that anyone with a complaint!, who practices in Kansas City, Mo., frequently files requests information. Inappropriate behavior, instead focusing on improper handling of the judicial process the use of such sources including., subject: your FOIA request DOJ-2018-008786 ( AG ) n't redact parts without citing FOIA... None of those deals with sexist or sexually inappropriate behavior, instead focusing on improper of... Reporting and responding to sexual harassment and misconduct Maps for a map and directions to Arlington... # 35 of 63 pending `` complex '' requests, men never answer that,! Your FOIA request DOJ-2018-008786 ( AG ) responsive to this request, and the Board of Appeals... Courtroom on time s 2021 pay is 22 % higher than the general. Place procedures to implement the guidance of public Health Noticefor more information pay is 22 % than., U.S. attorney general from 2017 to 2018, addresses incoming immigration judges into place procedures to implement the of. The legal profession, information is the key to success complaint should file it that his was! January 2012 anonymous sources: the Chronicle - the Executive Office for immigration Review EOIR! Was joking with willing colleagues, the report said documents are sent to and from Grants home, sources! Overhaul of the judicial process 1990s told the Chronicle that his behavior was frequently inappropriate Mo., frequently requests... Gender sensitivity training for its judges share sensitive information only on official, websites...
print maggard immigration judge rating